—Micheál Ó Seighin.1
“The human crisis is always a crisis of understanding: what we genuinely understand we can do.”
—Raymond Williams.2
Whose Culture?
In his multimedia project Sea Tamagotchi: Fóclóir Farraige, Irish writer and documentary filmmaker Manchán Magan writes of the different ways in which Irish-language words have captured ecological knowledge and maritime traditions in Ireland. He tells us that caileantóireacht denotes “forecasting the weather by noticing natural phenomena,” that buailteog is a “shaft, or ray of light, on the wrong side of the sun” (indicating a sign of bad weather approaching), and that gaoithe iascaireachta stores knowledge about winds “which are good and bad for fishing.”3 Developed as part of a Galway 2020 Project when Galway was the designated European Capital of Culture, Magan’s work focuses on gathering thirty-eight old and “lost” sea words, maritime phrases, and coastal customs. This fóclóir farraige (maritime dictionary) serves as both an ecological and linguistic toolkit, capturing words and phrases used by maritime communities along the west coast of Ireland in how to navigate their seascapes, interpret natural phenomena, and, crucially, how to read the sky and decode changing weather patterns. Such knowledge systems form part of what UNESCO terms Traditional Ecological Knowledge (TEK), and these systems therefore play a valuable role in helping communities understand and pass on knowledge of their environmental heritage. For some scholars and community activists TEK can also provide us with a way of rethinking how we may live more sustainably in our shared planetary home.
As Magan’s project reminds us, cultures and languages have traditionally played key roles in how environmental knowledge systems have been passed down intergenerationally within societies for millennia. Yet the important role that culture and language can and do play in helping us understand and critically reimagine alternative ecosocial solutions to our current planetary emergency has largely been either undervalued or critically elided in much of modern scientific and policy literature on the environment and sustainability. As Michael Cronin argues in An Ghaeilge agus an Éiceolaíocht/Irish and Ecology, language has to be regarded as a key critical infrastructure in addressing the existential challenges of climate change and biodiversity loss.4 He observes that in the Irish government’s Climate Action Plan 2019 there is no mention or meaningful discussion of language as being a critical part of government policy, planning, and competency. More worryingly, as Cronin observes, “in the 148 closely written pages of the Climate Action Plan, there is not one single mention of the Irish language.” And as language “situates people in their environment in terms of both description and narration—telling you where you are and what’s around you and where you come from—the project of removing Irish from public life has as one long-term consequence the alienation of people from their own surroundings.” In a wider frame of reference he warns of the risk taken when the power of language is underestimated and observes that “when no credence is given to the mythical power of language, myth-making of the most toxic kind will thrive.”5 This article addresses such concerns and makes reference in particular to the key role of language in the formation of cultural practices and sustainability policy in Irish and international contexts. In particular, two site-specific visual-arts projects that deal with ecological concerns will be discussed below.6 These artworks foreground, within an Irish bilingual context, a visual language of the climate crisis.
This article addresses the relationship between culture and the polycrises that are climate change and biodiversity loss and emphasizes how culture as a category needs to be reinstated and repositioned as part of any response.7 It argues that not only is there a “culture gap” in sustainability literature that ignores or undervalues the role that culture plays in relation to climate discourse and public policy, but also maintains that the very concept of “culture” itself has become problematically funneled and instrumentalized since the early 2000s.8 This can particularly be seen with the influence of urban theorist Richard Florida in relation to his ideas on culture as a driver of urban economic development since the publication of his book The Rise of the Creative Class in 2002. Such ideas have shaped urban regeneration projects internationally since then.9 As I have argued elsewhere, “culture in its broadest sense can help us connect with and critically imagine different ecological futures by enabling us to navigate and narrate solutions for the kind of nation we wish to build in the next 100 years and beyond. In brief, culture can help bridge the policy gap between climate ambition and climate action.”10 This present article extends that position and argues that a more expansive, decolonial, and feminist model of the sustainability paradigm needs to urgently recognize culture as the fourth pillar of sustainability, and that any future climate policies, actions, or goals should include this fourth pillar of culture along with the established three pillars of “society,” “economy,” and “environment.”11 Taking its lead from the writings of Hannah Arendt and Raymond Williams in particular, the article also asserts that culture as a concept needs to be rehabilitated and reexpanded, with culture as critique recognized as a key element of our societal infrastructure in the rethinking and reshaping of more equitable planetary futures.
In tracking the use and development of the term “culture” in international policy documents, the article first outlines the introduction and use of the concept of “culture” in such documents from the postwar Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948) to the more recent Sixth Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (2022) that acknowledges for the first time the “social and demand-side aspects of climate mitigation”12 and reported on “how social norms, culture, and individual choices interact with infrastructure and other structural changes over time.”13 As noted above, in recent years “culture” has become increasingly utilized as a term within a neoliberalizing discourse that seeks to “exploit” the cultural realm (whether in the arts, culture, or heritage sectors) primarily as a driver of economic growth and enabler of social cohesion.14 As Kenneth McLeod has argued in his influential position paper “Learning to Think Like a Planet,” culture is “a civilization’s shared way of making sense of the world: what is real, what is knowable, and what has value. . . . It conditions our ways of being, seeing, doing and imagining. It determines what we consider appropriate action in and on the world.”15
Writing closer to home, Our Story—The Rossport 5 documents the experiences of a local community with Enterprise Oil and Shell in relation to opposition to the development of the Corrib Gas Project and the onshore refining of gas near homes in their Gaeltacht village and townland of Ros Dubhach (Rossport), in northwest County Mayo, Ireland. In the book Micheál Ó Seighin writes of the importance of place, language, and identity to those in the area, and how all of the culture attached to the landscape of North Mayo was under threat owing to the infrastructural and environmental changes planned with the proposed gas-refinery project. As he explains, “culture” is not something to be seen in a gallery or experienced in a concert hall, but rather, “for us, the cultural aspect was very simple. When people talk about culture it’s a page in the Times that no one reads or the Sunday newspaper. But for us it’s a different thing, it’s all of living, everyday survival.”16 Ó Seighin here offers the best definition and description of the importance of culture as an integral and existential part of every aspect of his community’s lifeworld: “it’s all of living, everyday survival.”
The influence of what a more limited use and mis/understanding of term “culture” not only misses the point of what culture is, and how it functions more broadly as noted by McLeod above, but has also problematically contributed to the acceleration of the postcrash crisis of the financialization of housing, the gentrification of cities, and, ironically, the fragmentation of the social contract in Ireland and elsewhere—especially since the global financial crisis of 2007–8. As journalist Úna Mullaly has argued, we need to become a “culture-first society,” and “we cannot pretend to value art yet have cities that are hostile to artists.”17 This article argues that we need to rehabilitate culture in both policy and conceptual terms, and in particular to reenergize a certain mode of culture that treats it as critical practice. Informed by the writings of Hannah Arendt, I also argue that we need to remind ourselves of how culture can speak to, or “hold,” other kinds of truths—truths that may turn out to be critical in helping to maintaining a public sphere at a time of unprecedented geopolitical societal strain and fracture. As the analysis of the use of the term “culture” in such policies below demonstrates, the problem that still broadly remains is that in both scientific and public- policy discourses culture is still generally regarded as being a tool for science/policy communication. It is mostly deployed to raise scientific/policy awareness and can be used to motivate individuals/communities to engage with a desired behavioral change when it comes to meeting national targets and international goals such as the UN Sustainable Development Goals. The article concludes by arguing that more work needs to be done at national and international levels to expand and critique problematically outmoded sustainability narratives and to strategically include “culture” as the missing fourth pillar in all climate policies and to recognize it as a core societal infrastructure in addressing the existential challenges of our time.
From Human Rights to Climate Rights: “Culture” in International and Irish Policy
The Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR) is a key document in the origins of human-rights discourse of the last century. Drafted in the aftermath of the Second World War, the declaration was ratified by the United Nations General Assembly in Paris on 10 December 1948, setting out fundamental human rights. It has been subsequently translated into more than 500 languages. Article 27 of the Declaration states that “everyone has the right freely to participate in the culture life of the community, to enjoy the arts, and to share in scientific advancement and its benefits.” Furthermore (notwithstanding the gendering of the document) it affirms that “everyone has the right to the protection of the moral and material interests resulting from any scientific, literary, or artistic production of which he is the author.”18 Following on from this, Article 15 of the International Covenant on Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights (adopted on 16 December 1966 by the UN General Assembly) recognizes the right of everyone to “take part in cultural life,” “enjoy the benefits of scientific progress and its applications,” and to “benefit from the protection of the moral and material interests resulting from any scientific, literary, or artistic production of which he is the author.”19
A more recent policy paper on culture in relation to sustainable development emerged from the United Cities and Local Government (UCLG) and was entitled “Culture, the Fourth Pillar of Sustainable Development,” published in November 2010. Building on UNESCO’s Universal Declaration on Cultural Diversity (2001), the Executive Bureau of UCLG approved the policy statement that “culture is the fourth pillar of sustainable development” on 17 November 2010 within the framework of the World Summit of Local and Regional Leaders held in Mexico City that year. The UCLG document outlines the history of how ideas around sustainable development emerged in the 1980s with the publication of the now-infamous Bruntland Report entitled “Our Common Future” in 1987, which asserted that there were three pillars of sustainable development: “economic growth, social inclusion and environmental balance.” The Earth Summit in Rio de Janeiro in 1992 reconfirmed these three pillars in the creation of the sustainable-development paradigm. The UCLG document identifies a gap, however, with this model of sustainable development in that “these dimensions alone cannot possibly reflect the complexity of current society.” It further posits that “culture” needs to be integrated into the sustainable development paradigm in two ways: firstly “the development of the cultural sector itself,” and secondly by “ensuring that culture has its rightful place in all public policies.” Finally, it argues that culture as the “fourth pillar creates solid bridges with the other three dimensions,” and that “culture in all its diversity is needed to respond to the current challenges of humankind.”20
In May 2013 UNESCO adopted the Hangzhou Declaration, “Placing Culture at the Heart of Sustainable Development Policies,” in Hangzhou, People’s Republic of China. The declaration was the outcome of the UNESCO Culture: Key to Sustainable Development international congress. This was the first congress that focused specifically on the connections between culture and sustainable development organized by UNESCO since 1998 and provided a “global forum to discuss the role of culture in sustainable development in view of the United Nations post-2015 development agenda.”21 The Hangzhou Declaration affirms that international policy approaches “should fully acknowledge the role of culture as a system of values and a resource and framework to build truly sustainable development, the need to draw from past generations, and the recognition of culture as part of the global and local commons as well as a wellspring for creativity and renewal.” The document recalls previous policy documents such as “Keeping the Promise: United to Achieve the Millennium Development Goals” (2010) and the summary document of the UN Conference on Sustainable Development, “The Future We Want” (2012), which highlighted “the importance of cultural diversity and the need for a more holistic and integrated approach to sustainable development.” The Hangzhou Declaration reaffirms that “culture should be considered as a fundamental enabler of sustainability, being a source of meaning and energy, a wellspring of creativity and innovation, and a resource to address challenges and find appropriate solutions.” The power of culture is evident “when a people-centred and place-based approach is integrated into development programmes and peace-building initiatives.” Finally, it argues for “the full integration of culture—through clear targets, goals, and indicators—into agreed development strategies, programs, and practices at global, regional, national, and local levels, to be defined in the post-2015 UN development agenda.”22
With these statements, it is interesting to observe how “culture” is situated and how it permeates various international-policy documents, from human rights to children’s rights and from heritage concerns to climate policy in recent decades. At the sixth conference of the European Cultural Convention held in Namur, Belgium, in April 2015 the Council of Europe’s Committee of Ministers of Culture agreed on objectives and priorities for a future common European Heritage Strategy in relation to policies and principles in relation to the protection, conservation, and enhancement of cultural heritage in Europe. The Namur Declaration (as it would later become known) follows some of the recommendations made earlier in the Hangzhou Declaration.23 The Namur Declaration welcomes the European Union’s efforts to “give greater consideration to cultural heritage in its areas of expertise” (Namur Declaration, item iii). In section V it argues that “cultural heritage is a group of resources inherited from the past which people identify, independently of ownership, as a reflection and expression of their constantly evolving values, beliefs, knowledge, and traditions, including all aspects of the environment resulting from the interaction between people and places through time.” Section VII recognizes “the contribution of culture and cultural heritage to sustainable development, of which they form the ‘fourth pillar.’” What is of particular importance in the Namur Declaration is the reference to culture as the “fourth pillar” of sustainability in arguing for its importance alongside the other three pillars for EU sectoral policies.
The British Council questioned of the efficacy of the sustainable development goals (SDGs) with the publication of the report The Missing Pillar: Culture’s Contribution to the UN Sustainable Development Goals in October 2020. Here, Rosanna Lewis of the Council highlighted that while “culture is the glue that binds humanity together,” that “in the UN Agenda 2030 there is no specific goal on culture,” and it is not formally recognized alongside the three pillars of development. The report is positioned to highlight the connection between culture and sustainable development and advocates for “the value of culture as a fourth pillar of sustainable development.”24
The publication of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) sixth assessment report, AR6 Climate Change 2022: Mitigation of Climate Change, in 2022 marked a significant shift in that for the first time, “the social and demand-side aspects of climate mitigation” were included as part of the remit and consideration of an IPCC report.25 In particular, chapter 5, “Demand, Services and Social Aspects of Mitigation,” outlines “how social norms, culture, and individual choices interact with infrastructure and other structural changes over time.” The authors argue that social-science literature and regional case studies provide “new insight into climate change mitigation strategies, and how economic and social activity might be organized across sectors to support emission reductions.” They argue that “mitigation strategies can be classified as Avoid-Shift-Improve (ASI) options that reflect opportunities for sociocultural, infrastructural, and technological change.” The executive summary of the chapter adjudicates that there is “medium confidence” that “sociocultural and lifestyle changes can accelerate climate-change mitigation,” and “high confidence” that “demand-side mitigation options bring multiple interacting benefits,” but that different emissions implications “depend on local contexts, cultures, geography, available technologies, and social preferences.” They go on to argue (with “medium confidence”) that “cultural change, in combination with new or adapted infrastructure, is necessary to enable and realise many ‘Avoid’ and ‘Shift’ options,” and that “narratives of change can enable coalitions to form, providing the basis for social movements to campaign in favour of (or against) societal transformations.”26 Unfortunately, the authors of this chapter in the IPCC report miss an opportunity to call out the “culture gap” in relation to the enabling “narratives of change” and fail to clearly recognize culture as the fourth pillar.
In 2022 the Climate Heritage Network devised a manifesto for the future climate meetings of the UN Council of the Parties (COP) held in in Sharm El-Sheikh, Egypt, entitled “Imagining and Realising Climate Resilient Futures: The Power of Arts, Culture, and Heritage to Accelerate Climate Action.”27 This manifesto foregrounded the vital role of culture (and cultural heritage in particular) to society and states that “culture anchors people to places and to each other. It creates cohesion in unique ways: enabling community-building and collective action, providing shared moments, feelings, and commitments, inventing new symbols and new tool.” In addition, it maintains that “artists and cultural voices drive public awareness and action,” and that cultural centers, institutions, and organizations “provide platforms for listening to communities and hubs of multicultural and intergenerational exchange, capacity building and knowledge-sharing.”28 It argues that “artistic, creative, and imaginative tools hold transformative potential by challenging the values that condition life choices, including economic and consumption models and by supporting transformative reinterpretation of today’s carbonscapes and accompanying mindsets.”29 The manifesto aimed at providing key messages on the connection between culture and climate change at COP27 and in particular sought to “inspire and encourage greater synergistic collaboration on climate action with other sectors and partners that have not traditionally engaged with cultural actors.”30
In a European context, public funding in relation to how the arts, culture, and creative practices can be used “to shape social norms, to educate, and to enhance community engagement” has supported research projects and cultural programs across the EU in recent decades.31 In Ireland the potential of the cultural sector to educate the public as well as inspire and enact positive social and environmental change was recognized by the government’s Climate Action Plans of 2019 and again in 2024. In June 2019, with the Green Party as one of the three coalition parties then in power, the Irish government launched the “Climate Action Plan to Tackle Climate Breakdown,” a plan that identified the scale of the challenge to move Ireland’s economy and society toward the goal of net-zero carbon emissions by 2050. In response to this, Creative Ireland commissioned a report, “Engaging the Public on Climate Change through the Cultural and Creative Sectors,” that examined how the cultural and creative sectors could play “an essential role in enabling people to understand, interpret, and engage with many aspects of climate change.”32 The government’s Creative Climate Action Plan emerged from this broader policy, which is an ongoing government-led initiative that funds various artists, projects, and communities focused on increasing citizen engagement with national climate targets and EU climate policies.
Between 2021 and 2023 the Creative Climate Action Fund supported 15 creative projects, with the second phase of the fund expanding in 2023–24 to support forty-three projects valued at €5.8 million in total, three of which were part of the Shared Island initiative run by the Department of the Taoiseach supporting cross-border collaboration in the area of creative climate action. Speaking at the launch of phase two of the fund, then-taoiseach Leo Varadkar noted:
The inclusion of three significant cross-border projects in the Creative Climate Action Fund under the Shared Island initiative signifies the ongoing government support for ambitious activities which benefit the whole island and bring people together around common concerns. In this instance the funding will help to develop awareness, through creativity, of climate change, the single greatest threat facing humanity today. We must be the generation that turns the tide on climate change and biodiversity loss. The ongoing Shared Island dimension of the Creative Ireland Programme will harness the power of cultural creativity to bring communities together across the island.33
A national study that reviewed the impacts of creative climate-action initiatives in fostering citizen engagement is Creative C-Change: Analysing the Impact of the Creative Climate Action Initiative on Climate Change Awareness, Engagement, and Action in Ireland, led by Professor Marguarite Nyhan at University College Cork. This research study engaged with five selected Creative Ireland-funded Creative Climate Action projects and collected data from over sixty-five associated events during 2022–23. The joint authors of the Creative C-Change report state that up until this point “most efforts to engage the public have focused solely on engaging people on a cognitive level by communicating climate-change information which would serve to motivate action.” They argue that “understanding the problem is not enough, however, and people first need to be moved emotionally before they can be moved to act.” The report aims to capture “the impact of these arts, cultural, and creative projects and their events on climate-change awareness, engagement, and action in Ireland.”34
In summary, the Creative C-Change report outlines how these creative projects have “increased awareness, engagement, and action in relation to the environment and climate change,” with findings showing how the arts and creative communities “can play an extremely valuable role in enabling dialogue and engaging audiences in new perspectives and action on climate change.” In addition, the report argues that “it is essential to recognise the significant potential of the arts and cultural sector in fostering new and alternative responses to climate change action.”35 As Alison Tickell, CEO of Julie’s Bicycle in Scotland argues, “no amount of data, science, or technology can ever make us feel the world in the same way as art can.”36 While the Creative C-Change report is very valuable in highlighting the importance of using multiple research methods to capture the impact of creative projects (through the mixed uses of surveys, questionnaires, consultations, interviews, fieldwork, and desk-based research), it does so within the project aims of primarily measuring the policy utility of culture by framing the arts, culture, and creative practices as enablers or tools to help activate behavioral ecosocial change at individual and societal scales. The report does not explicitly include any discussion of culture as a fourth pillar of sustainability nor does it discuss the role of culture as critical practice in providing a public space for social critique more broadly.
Reclaiming Culture: Culture as Critical Practice
What can be seen in the above discussions is how “culture” as a general category is mostly assumed to function as a useful agent of social change and an instrument to deploy in the climate-action toolkit. While the incorporation of culture, the arts, and creative practices is to be welcomed in many of the climate policies cited above, the issue is when such categories are incorporated into climate policy in a prescribed and limited capacity. The danger of framing culture as a tool for change is that in such formations it is situated within a social-scientific frame of reference with its more radical potential for critical agency neutered more often than not. The 2022 IPCC report almost exclusively focuses on the social aspect of sociocultural opportunities for change, with the very chapter title itself highlighting the “social aspects of mitigation” and leaving out the cultural half of the equation, again confirming the wider gap in such discussions. This in turn indicates either a lack of understanding on the part of the authors (who mostly come from STEM or social-sciences disciplines) as to the full remit of the “socio-cultural” as a category of inquiry, or a broader general unease in engaging with the cultural aspects of climate policy, which are often seen as being of secondary importance if noted at all. A key implication here is that when the authors of such reports and policies do not have an expertise in arts and humanities disciplines it is very understandable then that the category or concept of culture recedes from policy view and climate action.
What is also missing in such texts is the idea of culture as the potential space for critical practice, in relation to the paradigm of what Jacques Rancière calls “critical art.” In “The Paradoxes of Political Art,” Rancière maintains that “artworks can produce effects of dissensus precisely because they neither give lessons nor have any destination.” In other words, artworks resist being incorporated into a given framework or function (“the effects of dissensus”) and demand the right to exist in and of themselves on their own terms. Critical art, he argues, is “art that aims to produce a new perception of the world, and therefore to create a commitment to its transformation.” Taking the examples of Bertholt Brecht, Jean Luc Goddard and Martha Rosler, Rancière argues that in the production of a form of “strangeness” and through a process of “dissociation” such art presents a “rupture in the specific configuration that allows us to stay in ‘our’ assigned places in a given state of things.” In a time of shrinking political space, he contends that this art “is starting to appear as a space of refuge for dissensual practice,” a place where relationships in the world continue to be “questioned and reworked.”37 In addition, I would also argue that a feminist and decolonial critical practice is also vitally important in considering the production of culture, with the potential of offering alternative futures because it provides differential (or dissensual) origins and starting points.
One example of such “critical art” in an Irish context is the Common? project by visual artist Fiona Woods, which was displayed in public spaces (bus stops, bike sheds, advertising boards) across Galway city as part of TULCA Arts Festival 2010 (figures 2 and 3). In this public artwork, Woods explores the relational aesthetics across species in provoking the view to rethink what “we” might have in common with other animal species. Themes in relation to patterns of consumption and food security, bodily integrity and freedom are addressed, along with questions handwritten on placards for the audience to contemplate in line with the image. The artworks all merge elements of human with nonhuman body parts and so arrest the viewer in a form of a “visual ambush” to reconsider what it means to be human or an animal.38
The bilingual public-art project Drowned Galway sought to engage the public with the impact of climate change with more severe storm surge and increased sea levels in different sites around the coastline. Devised by choreographer Ríonach Ní Néill in association with filmmaker Joe Lee, the project asks the public to consider “An féidir leatsa siúl ar bharr an uisce?” (“Can you walk on water?”) and installed a series of photomontages around iconic areas of Galway city as visual prompts and propositions asking viewers to consider that particular question in that specific place. This series of site-specific artworks were installed around the city as part of a wider Galway 2020 funded project curated by Ní Néill entitled Soinneann nó Doinnean/Hope It Rains, many of which still remain on view today. According to the artist statement,
Is sraith ealaíne é Drowned Galway ina léiríonn saothair fótamontáis, scannán, dearadh teicstíle, dealbhóireacht, ceol & taibhiú saol agus cathair na Gaillimhe faoi thoinn. Cé chomh gar dúinn a chaithfidh an baol a theacht go dtí go rachaimid i mbun gníomhaíochta?
Drowned Galway is a multimedia series of works comprising large-format photomontages, film, textile designs, sculpture, music, and performance, visualising life in a near-future inundated city. Find yourself immersed in a near-future Galway, where the abnormal has become normal, and floods and sea-level rising have transformed the city. How close does the future have to come before we care enough to act?39
In addition to the photomontage posters, the project also had guided tours of the distressed climate sites, an audio map (with interviews with the local community members, artists, activists, and scholars of climate change), a film, and a performance-based element to the project. Drowned Galway foregrounded how climate futures are already here with us and offered physical and visual reminders to the public that this small city on the edge of Europe is part of the wider planetary shift in our shared ecological futures. Moreover, it was a fully bilingual intervention in which Irish was the working language of the majority of the project. As a scientifically informed but artist-led project foregrounding cultural modes of environmental knowledge creation, Drowned Galway was an exemplar as to how site-specific or socially engaged arts practice can positively work to shift the narrative (monolingual and otherwise) and enact positive social change.
Culture, or culture as socially engaged or public-arts practice, often becomes an adage to many larger STEM-oriented climate projects and funding streams that have to show how such projects will “engage” with various publics to “educate” them on knowledge mostly generated by climate science. Artists are very often brought in as a mechanism for climate-knowledge transfer (which is mostly seen as being unidirectional, with data emerging from scientific experts going “out” and then across different platforms to various publics), and not primarily for data collection or climate knowledge generation in themselves. In such instances, the arts, or cultural practices more broadly, are not fully recognized for their capacity to hold open a critical space for public dialogue that may not be just socially “transformational” but a radically alternative opening for knowledge generation and future ways of thinking and being.
The dangers inherent in this limited form of engaging with culture and the arts is that a vacuum can open up in the public realm when other concerns, or “truths,” are ignored, ridiculed, or dismissed out of hand. The limits of cognitive engagement and the realization that facts on their own do not convince or compel people to change their minds was noted by Hannah Arendt in her essay “Truth and Politics,” published in The New Yorker on 25 February 1967 and written in the aftermath of the controversy associated with her book Eichmann in Jerusalem. Here, in considering questions as to how people did nothing during the Holocaust or failed to believe the facts of what happened, Arendt stresses that “factual truth is no more self-evident than opinion, and this may be among the reasons that opinion-holders find it relatively easy to discredit factual truth as just another opinion.”40 That there are “other kinds” of truths that people hold dear, many of which may override the “factual truths” of science or rational argument, is the focus of her argument here. Such truths (whether personal, spiritual, social, cultural, or political) often are aligned with the value system that shapes and informs a person’s beliefs and actions. And if these “other truths” are missed or dismissed, the danger is that there will be a mismatch at best, or fracturing at worst, in terms of how people see themselves within a sociopolitical system that may or may not give them value and meaning.
Arendt was highly aware of the dangers in such critical gaps in understanding, and as she argues in Between Past and Present, there is a high price to pay for not recognizing that the old systems and vocabularies no longer “fit” or serve the contemporary. As she explains,
The situation, however, became desperate when the old metaphysical questions were shown to be meaningless; that is, when it began to dawn upon modern man that he had come to live in a world in which his mind and his tradition of thought were not even capable of asking adequate, meaningful questions, let alone of giving answers to its own perplexities. In this predicament action, with its involvement and commitment, its being engagée, seemed to hold out the hope, not of solving any problems, but of making it possible to live with them without becoming, as Sartre once put it, a salaud, a hypocrite . . . .41
For Arendt, the issue was the need to recognize the eclipse of tradition, religion, and authority in the modern era. And that this same tradition has “worn thinner and thinner as the modern age progressed is a secret to nobody.”42 Modernity entailed the loss of the world and the dislocation of our relationship to the earth from the seventeenth century on, culminating in what she terms “world alienation” from the rise of the natural sciences in the early modern period and yielding “earth alienation” from the mid-twentieth-century technological advances that push beyond our planetary boundaries to the moon and that challenge the very limits of what it means to be human.43
Written in the aftermath of the Second World War and as part of the New Left wave of cultural critics, Raymond Williams published his groundbreaking Culture and Society, 1780–1950 in 1958. The book reimagined the role and function of criticism in society for postwar generation of critics and scholars and set in motion the development of a new field, cultural studies, in foregrounding the “social relations” inherent between culture and politics. In his opening paragraph Williams clarifies that “the organising principle for this book is the discovery that the idea of culture, and the word itself in its general modern uses, came into English thinking in the period which we commonly describe as that of the Industrial Revolution.” In taking a conception of culture as “a theory of relations between elements of a whole way of life” Williams notes how the use of the term culture has changed since the Enlightenment. Originally a term denoting “the tending of natural growth” and then “by analogy, a process of human training,” Williams identifies how culture had transformed by the eighteenth century from being a process of something to “culture as such, a thing in itself.” He argues that “the development of the word culture is a record of a number of important and continuing reactions to these changes in our social, economic, and political life, and may be seen, in itself, as a special kind of map by means of which the nature of the changes can be explored.”44
In Keywords: A Vocabulary of Culture and Society (1976) Williams extends such discussions on culture and succinctly states that:
Culture is one of the two or three most complicated words in this English language. This is so partly because of its intricate historical development, in several European languages, but mainly because it has now come to be used for important concepts in several distinct intellectual disciplines and in several distinct and incompatible systems of thought.45
Williams outlines how culture is derived from the Latin colere, which “had a range of meanings: inhabit, cultivate, protect, honour with worship,” and stresses that culture was a noun of process in its early uses. Culture then became a synonym for civilization in the eighteenth century as used by historians and philosophers of the Enlightenment. From this period on, Williams notes, culture as a term denoted three broad categories: 1) culture as an abstract noun that “describes a general process of intellectual, spiritual, and aesthetic development” from the eighteenth century; 2) culture as an “independent noun” that “indicates a particular way of life, whether of a people, a period, a group, or humanity in general, from Herder and Klemm”; and 3) culture as an “independent and abstract noun” that “describes the works and practices of intellectual and especially artistic activity.” It is this third sense of culture, he observes, that is “often now the most widespread use: culture is music, literature, painting and sculpture, theatre and film.”46 Following this, with the connection between culture, art, skill, and industry in the eighteenth century, came the idea of art as “a special kind of truth,” what Williams terms an “imaginative truth,” with the artist having the status in society as being “a special kind of person.”47 What Williams is pointing to here is the idea of how culture, and the arts in particular, may signify or proffer other kinds of truths to a given society.
In his concluding chapter to Culture and Society Williams makes observations in the aftermath of the atomic bomb. He writes of his concerns of how a knot has been “tied” to humanity that has “come near to strangling our whole common life in this century. We live in almost overwhelming danger, at a peak of our apparent control. We react to the danger by attempting to take control, yet still we have to unlearn, as the price of survival, the inherent dominative mode.”48 The idea of having to “unlearn” the “inherent dominative mode” is the practice of critique he is developing here as a way to unravel and reformulate the ties that bind culture to society.49 For Williams the danger is that ‘‘we project our old images onto the future and take hold of ourselves and others to force energy towards that substantiation. We do this as conservatives, trying to prolong the old forms; we do this as socialists, trying to prescribe the new man.” In critically recognizing the ills of society, and where the possible solutions may lie, he observes that:
The evident problems of our civilization are too close and too serious for anyone to suppose that an emphasis is a solution. In every problem we need hard, detailed inquiry and negotiation. Yet we are coming increasingly to realize that our vocabulary, the language we use to inquire into and negotiate our actions, is no secondary factor, but a practical and radical element in itself. To take a meaning from experience, and to try to make it active, is in fact our process of growth. Some of these meanings we receive and re-create. Others we must make for ourselves, and try to communicate. The human crisis is always a crisis of understanding: what we genuinely understand we can do.50
What Williams is foregrounding here is the critical insight that language does not merely mirror or reflect “reality” but is integrally constitutive of it. Language here is reframed as agent of thought, not just as a passive actor or reciter of lines composed elsewhere. In his introduction to Keywords he emphasizes this critical point again when he insists that “the most active problems of meaning are always primarily embedded in actual relationships, and that both the meanings and the relationships are typically diverse and variable within structures of particular social orders and the processes of social and historical change.” This, he continues,
does not mean that the language simply reflects the processes of society and history. On the contrary, it is a central aim of this book to show that some important social and historical processes occur within language, in ways which indicate how integral the problems of meanings and of relationships really are. New kinds of relationship, but also new ways of seeing existing relationships, appear in language in a variety of ways.51
The key point from Williams’s writings is his important reminder to us that culture per se does not reflect society but rather, as an expressive system of a society’s values, is constitutive of it. Indeed, I would go further to emphasize that culture, in its broadest meaning, generates new languages, vocabularies, and knowledges. The difficulty here is that because the operation of culture is sometimes “invisible” or difficult to pin down and capture (as it operates in a different mode of meaning, value, and significance to that of scientific discourse), this is one fundamental reason why a western-scientific model or positivist ontology cannot “see” or “process” culture fully. Therefore, such analytic modes of enquiry are unable to fully recognize and value the generative capacity of culture to develop new knowledges and hold other ways of being in the world.52
Our Cultures, Our Futures
The citizen, student, teacher, commentator, artist, and public scholar who is concerned with all of these issues examined here is already embedded within a “complex nexus of responsibility.”53 Threats to knowledge, democracy, institutions, and the vital independence of the academy are all potentially at stake in this uncertain period. Threats to life, present and future, are evident in the current geopolitical situations with the war in Ukraine and the erasure of conditions for bare life in Gaza. The future threat to ecological survival is evident with every weather report and instance of species extinction that accompanies wars, unprecedented flooding, fires, droughts, and heatwaves, with the European continent at the ironic epicenter of global heating, warming up faster than any other continent on the planet.
We have moved from an era of a sustainability agenda in Europe with the EU Green New Deal to one of securitization with fortress Europe seeking to expand its military readiness and with proposals to increase NATO spending targets from two to five percent of GDP. Fueled by concerns over the potential of the war in Ukraine to breach other European borders, along with the geopolitical shifts associated with US global realignment, in March 2025 the EU unveiled a €800 billion militarization plan known as “ReARM Europe Plan/Readiness 2030” in order to plan for “defence readiness” and with the aim of keeping the manufacture of “hard defence” (tanks, bombs, missiles) as “made in Europe.”54 Part of ReARM entails the launching of a €150 billion loan instrument—Security Action for Europe (SAFE)—that will help countries invest in key defense areas like missiles, drones, and cybersecurity. The color of the continent has therefore arguably shifted from the green sustainability agenda to the grey agenda of increased militarization. Such a realignment of funds may well impact health, education, and environmental budgets that can not only damage the efficacy of such priorities but may also accelerate social inequality and thus drive far-right narratives, which may in turn ironically threaten the very democracies that such policies were meant to bolster and support from within in the first place.
In his foundational essay “Tradition,” folklorist Henry Glassie argues that rather than “erecting and polishing a new definition” of the concept of “tradition,” it is more important to develop “an understanding of the concept in the breadth of its semantic extent.” Writing on the idea of “keywords” in folklore studies with the influence of Williams very much evident in the margins, Glassie maintains that while histories are “accounts of the past,” tradition is “the resource out of which people create,” and as history and tradition exclude more than they include they “remain open to endless revision.” Glassie is here concerned about the attribution of meaning to such histories and traditions, and the sociocultural values that their stories and practices contain is what is of interest to the folklorist and cultural historian. He continues with his exploration of how we can find and interpret what is meaningful to individuals and their societies when “most of that which makes up life, and makes it endurable, is neglected in history because it cannot be gracefully assimilated into hearty narratives of violent change.”
Folklore and vernacular art traditions are some avenues through which we can find such expressions of culture and endurance, Glassie argues. In writing on Braudel’s ideas on the writing of history, he argues that Braudel needed for his Annales project “a tough, pliable idea of tradition that would have allowed him to collect continuity and revolution into a useful approximation of the past.” This idea of needing a “tough, pliable idea of tradition” can be transposed to rehabilitate our current idea of culture to become once again a concept that is expansive enough to encompass its etymological origins and historical contexts while also being pliable in conceptual breadth. With this more expansive idea of culture we can retain continuity with its past and origins while also making space for new ways to consider how culture functions and operates in our given era. To rescue culture from the highly reductive concepts of creativity (and its first cousin, innovation) in rereading Williams’s writings we are minded to bring culture back to its more active and agential origins of tending, cultivation, and care. As Glassie also reminds us, “the fact that cultures and traditions are created, invented—willfully compiled by knowledgeable individuals—seems a surprise to scholars who cling to superorganic concepts and who invent, in order to sharpen spurious contrasts, uninvented, natural traditions.” He surmises that “culture and tradition, we have come to accept, are created by individuals out of experience. They have reasons for their actions, and their actions entail change.”55 One could go further to add that their actions not only necessarily entail change but rather that they provide the necessary conditions for the very possibility of change, and thus the necessary contexts for the creation of new questions and paradigm shifts and so contribute to the necessary conditions needed for hope in these dark times.
The matter of recognizing the problem, and naming it, is thus a very good place to start. As this article has argued, we need to challenge the dominant sustainability paradigm by integrating the vital category of culture into all ecosocial and environmental-systems thinking and sustainability policies. In addition, in recognizing that culture contains, represents, and shapes systems of values, we also have to make space “to live with the problems” as earlier articulated by Arendt for critique and critical practices so that we remind ourselves how language and culture critically inform the dominant scientific, economic, and political systems and modes of thought.56 We need to regard culture not just as communicator of science and agent of sociopolitical change but also as re/generator of old and new knowledges and critical incubator of alternative paradigms that may help shape our shared planetary futures. As Williams cautions, “there are ideas and ways of thinking with the seeds of life in them, and there are others, perhaps deep in our minds, with the seeds of a general death. Our measure of success in recognizing these kinds, and in naming them making possible their common recognition, may be literally the measure of our future.”57 We urgently need to reclaim the idea of culture in order to retain critical spaces now and for future generations.
Acknowledgements
First thoughts in relation to this article were offered at the Sustainability and Irish Culture Symposium, Princess Grace Irish Library, Monaco, in October 2023. I am very grateful to the symposium codirectors Professor Joseph Lennon and Ms. Susan Kelly von Medicus, and to Dr. Jonathan O’Neill and all colleagues for their responses to ideas first explored there. Many thanks to the two peer reviewers for their insightful suggestions that have helped to refine my arguments. Further research for this article was conducted during a joint GATES Senior Research Fellowship at the Maison de la Création et de l’innovation (MaCI), Université Grenoble Alpes, and at St. Cross College, University of Oxford, in 2024, and with much-welcomed general discussion at a plenary lecture that I delivered on this theme at the ASLE-UKI Biennial Conference in August 2025. Míle buíochas, and with much gratitude, to artists Fiona Woods, Ríonach Ní Néill, and Joe Lee for permission to reproduce their artworks. Finally, I would also like to finally thank my BA students at the Centre for Irish Studies in Galway who have shared their concerns and hopes with me in relation to the pivotal role that culture can play in addressing the existential questions of our times. Míle buíochas ó chroí.
Notes
Micheál Ó Seighin quoted in Mark Garavan et al., Our Story—The Rossport 5 (2006; Small World Media, 2007), 78. Emphasis added.
Raymond Williams, Culture and Society: 1780–1950 (1958; Vintage, 2017), 442.
Manchán Magan, Sea Tamagotchi: Fóclóir Farraige (Red Fox Press, 2020), n.p. Magan explains in this introductory page to the book that the idea to develop “Gaeilge Tamagotchi” was embarked upon in 2015, inspired by the Japanese “tamagotchi” toys that have to be nourished and nurtured to stay alive, and that the Fóclóir Farraige emerged from that initial concept.
Michael Cronin, Irish and Ecology/An Ghaeilge agus an Éiceolaíocht (Foilseacháin Ábhair Spioradálta, 2019), 5–11.
Cronin, Irish and Ecology, 5, 9, 7.
Other socially engaged transdisciplinary art projects in relation to engaging with the climate and biodiversity crises in an Irish-language or bilingual contexts that I do not unfortunately have time to discuss in more detail here include the Dinnseanchas Atlantic Uplands project by Hometree; Dr. Anita McKeown’s work with the EPA-funded project CoDesRes in An Daingean and Corca Dhuibhne more widely; and Lisa Fingleton as artist-in-residence with Corca Dhuibhne Inbhuanaithe, a Creative Ireland funded project in An Corca Dhuibne West Kerry Gaeltacht region. In the Scottish context the Climate Hebrides project has been exploring climate terminology in Scots Gàidhlig, and hosted the inaugural Gaelic Climate Convention with the publication of the Gaelic Climate Convention Report in association with the Outer Hebrides Climate Hub in November 2023, supported by the Scottish Government Net Zero initiative. See Ionad Gnàth-shìde Innse Gall, Gnàth-shìde & Gàidhlig, Nov. 2023, https://climatehebrides.com/climate-hub/resources. See also Cormac Cleary, “Doomsday Environmentalism: Socio-Environmental Justice beyond Hope in Gaelic Scotland,” Environmental Sociology (2025): 1–12, https://doi.org/10.1080/23251042.2025.2512605.
In this article I use the terms “climate change” and “climate” as shorthand to encompass the wider ecological and environmental planetary polycrises.
David Maggs, John Robinson, and Leanna Butters position the “culture gap” in relation to the climate crisis as primarily being “the difference between a society’s need to engage with itself at the level of ontology or ‘being’ and the capacity of its discourse and institutions to do so.” See David Maggs, John Robinson, and Leanna Butters, “The Culture Gap in the Climate Crisis,” Mitigation and Adaptation Strategies for Global Change 30:22 (2025), https://doi.org/10.1007/s11027-025-10209-w.
Richard Florida, The Rise of the Creative Class (Basic Books, 2002).
See Nessa Cronin, “Culture and Climate Change,” in Ireland’s Climate Change Assessment, Volume 4: Realising the Benefits of Transition and Transformation, ed. Róisín Moriarty, Tadhg O’Mahony, Agnieszka Stefaniec, Jean L. Boucher, Brian Caulfield, Hannah Daly, and Diarmuid Torney (Environmental Protection Agency, 2023), 193.
I am grateful to colleagues Dr. Cathy Fitzgerald and Dr. Conor Newman for discussions on this that have greatly helped shape my knowledge and ideas on the subject. See also Cathy Fitzgerald’s ecoliteracy work in advocating for an ecological cultural shift at https://haumea.ie and her engagement with the Earth Charter in 2000, which advocated for a “culture of peace” and an acknowledgement of a diversity of cultures in relation to the ecosocial challenges of the new century: “History,” Earth Charter, 2024, https://earthcharter.org/about-the-earth-charter/history.
Petteri Taalas and Inger Andersen, “Foreword,” in Climate Change 2022: Mitigation of Climate Change. Contribution of Working Group III to the Sixth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, ed. P. R. Shukla et al. (Cambridge University Press, 2022), v.
F. Creutzig et al., “Demand, Services, and Social Aspects of Mitigation” in Shukla et al., eds., Climate Change 2022, 505.
While I do not have space to fully engage with a detailed critique of Florida’s ideas here, the initial response to his 2002 book The Rise of the Creative Class propelled Florida to the status of being heralded as the “rockstar of regeneration” and the “prophet of placemaking.” As noted by Oliver Wainwright, the “creative city” theory was not without its critics, with some noting how “Florida’s formula has proven to benefit the already rich, mostly white middle class; fuel rampant property speculation; displace the bohemians he so fetishised; and see the problems that once plagued the inner cities simply move out to the suburbs.” The main issue was the exclusion of what he terms “the service class” within such urban policies (notwithstanding the questionable division of society into such “classes,” and that it appears to ignore the fact that many artists also have to work in the service and other industries to make ends meet), and that “inclusion” had to be part of the creative tech/urban regenerative model of economic prosperity. His followup book, The New Urban Crisis (2017) sought to address such issues, with many of its critics seeing his theories as being part of the problem and not the solution to the growing housing and urban crisis. See Oliver Wainright, “‘Everything Is Gentrification Now’: But Richard Florida Isn’t Sorry,” The Guardian, 26 Oct. 2017, https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2017/oct/26/gentrification-richard-florida-interview-creative-class-new-urban-crisis. It is of note that in summer 2013 Florida visited postcrash Dublin, where he was interviewed by Ann O’Dea, and he argued that in Ireland “you can see it here in this great country in things like agriculture, with artisan production. Farming is turning into a creative industry. Now we have to creatify the jobs of the people who take care of our parents, of our kids, who serve us in hotels, in restaurants—that’s the next frontier. We’ve got to creatify those jobs.” He further argues that “demand in the long run comes from building a class system of workers who can stimulate demand because their wages are high enough to buy the products we produce.” See Ann O’Dea, “Interview: Richard Florida—Talent Loves Tolerance,” Silicone Republic, 15 Aug. 2013, https://www.siliconrepublic.com/careers/interview-richard-florida-talent-loves-tolerance.
Kenneth McLeod, “Learning to Think Like a Planet,” ATP Discussion Paper, Oct. 2018, Institute for Interdisciplinary Research into the Anthropocene, https://iiraorg.com/2018/10/21/learning-to-think-like-a-planet, archived at https://perma.cc/WJ9W-984X.
Ó Seighin, Our Story, 78. Emphasis added.
Úna Mullaly, “We Need to Become a Culture-First Society,” Irish Times, 26 July 2021, https://www.irishtimes.com/opinion/una-mullally-we-need-to-become-a-culture-first-society-1.4630043.
Universal Declaration of Human Rights, United Nations, 1948, article 27, https://www.un.org/en/about-us/universal-declaration-of-human-rights.
International Covenant on Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights, United Nations, 16 December 1966, article 15, https://www.ohchr.org/en/instruments-mechanisms/instruments/international-covenant-economic-social-and-cultural-rights.
“Culture, the Fourth Pillar of Sustainability,” United Cities and Local Governments, 17 November 2010, https://www.agenda21culture.net/documents/culture-fourth-pillar-sustainability, archived at https://perma.cc/2CA7-TQAD, items 1–3; n.p.
“The Hangzhou Declaration: Placing Culture at the Heart of Sustainable Development Policies,” UNESCO, 3, https://unesdoc.unesco.org/ark:/48223/pf0000221238.
“Hangzhou Declaration,” 4–5.
See “Namur Declaration Calls for a European Strategy for Heritage,” Europa Nostra, 24 April 2015, https://www.europanostra.org/namur-declaration-calls-european-strategy-heritage, archived at https://perma.cc/E4SJ-2XTM. For the full text of the Namur Declaration online, see https://rm.coe.int/16806a89ae.
See Rosanna Lewis, “The Missing Pillar: Culture’s Contribution to the UN Sustainable Development Goals,” British Council, Oct. 2020, https://www.britishcouncil.org/research-insight/the-missing-pillar-sdgs, archived at https://perma.cc/TG56-3WTK.
Taalas and Andersen, “Foreword,” v.
F. Creutzig et al., “Demand, Services, and Social Aspects of Mitigation” in Shukla et al., eds., Climate Change 2022, 505–6.
The Council of the Parties (COP) is the main decision-making body of the United Nations Framework Convention for Climate Change (UNFCCC). It includes representatives of all the “Parties,” i.e., countries that have agreed to participate in and be bound by the UNFCCC, and was first held in Berlin, Germany in 1995. See “Conference of the Parties,” United Nations Climate Change, n.d., https://unfccc.int/process/bodies/supreme-bodies/conference-of-the-parties-cop, archived at https://perma.cc/5T2T-28A5.
See “Imagining and Realising Climate Resilient Futures: The Power of Arts, Culture, and Heritage to Accelerate Climate Action,” Climate Heritage Manifesto for COP27, Climate Heritage Network, 2022, 2, https://www.climateheritage.org/manifesto, archived at https://perma.cc/L8V2-T8KL.
“Imagining and Realising Climate Resilient Futures,” 3. For more on the challenges of changing mindsets and environmental paradigm shifts needed, see Nessa Cronin, “Environmentalities: Speculative Imaginaries of the Anthropocene,” in Routledge International Handbook of Irish Studies, ed. Renée Fox, Mike Cronin, and Brian Ó Conchubhair (Routledge, 2020), 349–61.
“Imagining and Realising Climate Resilient Futures,” 6.
As noted by Joanne Mac Mahon et al., “Arts, Creative, and Cultural Initiatives for Citizen Engagement on Climate Action: Insights from Ireland’s Creative Climate Action Fund,” Current Research in Environmental Sustainability 9 (2025): 1–12, 3, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.crsust.2024.100274.
See “Climate Change and the Creative and Cultural Sectors,” Creative Ireland, n.d., https://www.creativeireland.gov.ie/en/news/climate-change-and-the-cultural-and-creative-sectors, archived at https://perma.cc/9PWN-XPMX.
See “€5.8M Funding Announced New Creative Climate Action Fund II,” Creative Ireland, 14 July 2023, https://www.creativeireland.gov.ie/en/news/e5-8m-funding-announced-for-creative-cultural-and-artistic-initiatives-under-the-new-creative-climate-action-fund-ii, archived at https://perma.cc/87CS-VWNK.
Marguerite Nyhan, Alexandra Revez, Joanne Mac Mahon, Michelle Burke, Padraig Hogan, Creative C-Change: Analysing the Impact of the Creative Climate Action Initiative on Climate Change Awareness, Engagement & Action in Ireland, 2023, https://hdl.handle.net/10468/16113, 2.
Nyhan et al., Creative C-Change, 3.
Alison Tickell, interview by Erica Sweeney, “How the Arts and Culture Sector Can Drive Climate-Change Action,” Business Insider, 28 Oct. 2021, https://www.businessinsider.com/cop26-event-culture-missing-link-artists-drive-climate-change-action-2021-10, archived at https://perma.cc/7JU4-73FT.
Jacques Rancière, “The Paradoxes of Political Art,” in Dissensus: On Politics and Aesthetics, ed. and trans. Steven Corcoran (Bloomsbury, 2015), 148, 150–51, 153.
The term “visual ambush” resonates very well here with Rancière’s concept of “critical art” and is taken from an excellent review of TULCA 2010 by Christina Mullen, “TULCA, Various Venues, Galway, November 2010,” Circa Art Magazine, 22 Jan. 2011, https://circaartmagazine.net/tulca-various-venues-galway-november-2010.
Artist statement, Drowned Galway, https://www.hopeitrains.ie/index.php/en/drowned-galway, archived at https://perma.cc/9EMP-PTLD.
Hannah Arendt, “Truth and Politics,” in Between Past and Future: Eight Exercises in Political Thought (Penguin Classics, 2006), 239.
Arendt, Between Past and Future, 8.
Arendt, Between Past and Future, 13.
See Hannah Arendt, “Tradition and the Modern Age,” in Between Past and Future, especially pp. 25–27. While Arendt regards the advance of totalitarian regimes in the twentieth century as rupturing the Western tradition of political thought, it could easily be argued that this tradition was already broken with the European traditions of colonialism and slavery in earlier centuries.
Raymond Williams, Culture and Society: 1780–1950 (1958; Vintage, 2017), xiii, 4, 6. Emphasis as in the original.
Raymond Williams, Keywords: A Vocabulary of Culture and Society (1976; Fontana Press, 1988), 86. Emphasis as in the original. Interestingly, Williams also notes that “nature” is “perhaps the most complex word in the language.” See Keywords, 219.
Williams, Keywords, 86, 90.
Williams, Culture and Society, 4.
Williams, Culture and Society, 440.
For more on the process of unlearning the dominative mode of the human relationship to the environment, see Cronin, “Environmentalities.”
Williams, Culture and Society, 440, 442.
Williams, Keywords, 22. Emphasis as in the original.
See also “The Climate Issue” of The Stinging Fly Irish literary magazine for a broad range of contributions and in particular the roundtable discussion with Catherine Cleary, Nessa Cronin, Saoirse Exton, Pádraig Fogarty, and Kenneth Keavey, “Climate Roundtable: Where Do We Go From Here?,” in “The Climate Issue,” special issue, The Stinging Fly 53:3 (Winter 2025–26): 81–91.
I have adapted this phrase from Henry Glassie, who uses it to describe the relationship between a performer and the social world of their community. See Henry Glassie, “Tradition,” Journal of American Folklore 108:430 (1995): 402.
See “Acting on Defense to Protect Europeans,” European Commission, 19 Nov. 2025, https://commission.europa.eu/topics/defence/future-european-defence_en, archived at https://perma.cc/2BSP-CE4K.
Glassie, “Tradition,” 395–96, 398.
This concept would later be famously reformulated later by Donna Harraway as “staying with the trouble.” See Donna Harraway, Staying with the Trouble: Making Kin in the Chthulucene (Duke University Press, 2016).
Williams, Culture and Society, 442.