What have you done with what was given you, what have you done with the blue, beautiful world?1
In his memoir-travelogue The Sea Inside, Philip Hoare writes, “The sea defines us, connects us, separates us. Most of us experience only its edges, our available wilderness on a crowded island—it’s why we call our coastal towns ‘resorts,’ despite their air of decay. [ . . . ] Perpetually renewing and destroying, the sea proposes a beginning and an ending, an alternative to our landlocked state, an existence to which we are tethered when we might rather be set free.”2 Hoare’s writing career has been largely focused on the affective and cultural relationships between humanity and the planet’s seas, capturing the ambivalences and anxieties of our ties to our marine origins.3 In his works seascapes, beaches, and shorelines enthrall writers, artists, and tourists, bewitching and summoning their rhythmic reminders of the emergence of all earthly life. These topographies are mutable and volatile, abundant with living creatures yet latent with forces of scarcely imaginable violence, and they provide the basis of life itself to a human species that is increasingly negligent of its ecological imprints on land and at sea. The declining health and well-being of such marine ecologies cannot be disaggregated from the ongoing and future habitability of the planet for both human and nonhuman life-forms. Whether through rising sea temperatures or rising sea levels, humanity cannot escape the accruals of anthropogenic climate change. And while vast tracts of human and nonhuman life may currently live and thrive far from coastal regions, they are not insulated from the degradation of the seas.
A key question is how such populations can be informed about or, more forcefully, be confronted with the affective energies and lived realities of stark ecological decline. The uncanny has the capacity to disrupt the consolations of the familiar and intimate. Bringing it into critical and creative conversations on climate change disrupts familiar consolations and is highly suggestive. The title of Derek Mahon’s final poetic collection Washing Up (2020) links the author’s late works with his earlier publications. Mahon has long been drawn to write about seascapes, and his “poems are indeed pervaded with his sense of the seminality.”4 And while this pedigree will be acknowledged here, the primary focus will be on his collection Washing Up and specifically on its poems “Atlantis,” “Wrack,” “Dulse,” and “Kelp.” This analysis will alight upon the uncanny as well as other key ecocritical notions such as temporal and spatial scales, human and more-than-human relationships, and the role of eco-poetics and eco-aesthetics in the contemporary context.
Humanity retains the physical and affective traces of its marine origins, most acutely at the outset of our biological lives; thus, the current and ongoing degradation of the planet’s marine ecologies is bleakly ironic. Yet this is also where the Freudian uncanny is germane to conversations on, and understandings of, global climate crises. In The Uncanny Freud insists that the “uncanny is that class of the terrifying which leads back to something long known to us, once very familiar.”5 Later in the same essay he makes the related point that the “uncanny is in reality nothing new or foreign, but something familiar and old—established in the mind that has been estranged only by the process of repression.”6 In the context of ongoing planetary climate crises, the senses and experiences of disturbance and unpredictability associated with Freud’s concept are self-evident. Shared global ecologies—marine and aquatic—are left unstable by the impacts of anthropogenic climate changes. Consequently, the familiar temporal and spatial coordinates of many human and nonhuman communities and organisms are no longer secure—for so many local constituencies, the fixities of the homely are increasingly sundered. Indeed, Robert Macfarlane touches upon this very phenomenon in his engagement with scale and deep time. In his 2020 volume Underland Macfarlane addresses the experience of “solastalgia,” a condition that can be thought of in terms of “a modern uncanny, in which a familiar place is rendered unrecognizable by climate change or corporate action: the home become unhomely around its inhabitants.”7 Humanity is compelled to confront the accruals of centuries of ecological exploitation and degradation; in gothic form, the sins of the past appear to haunt the present and presage a degraded planetary future. But from another point of view, a less apocalyptic iteration of the uncanny might be divined. Donna Haraway maintains that a “layered, curious practice of becoming-with others for a habitable, flourishing world.”8 In the light of the displacement of entrenched species-hierarchies, Haraway calls for more empathetic and non-hierarchical ethical and environmental politics. Following Haraway might we suggest that ecological commonsense in its turn pushes our critical conversation back to Freud’s uncanny? Haraway’s summons that humanity partake of a more equitable and inclusive disposition renders the physical world unfamiliar. It might be legitimate to speak of an uncanniness that is engendered by having to open ourselves to the deeply historical and pervasive mutualities across species boundaries. The imprints of global ecological emergencies are certainly uncanny, but, as Haraway indicates in a more positive direction, humanity can and must come to terms with the uncertainties and the instabilities that accrue from a recognition and an acceptance of ecological intimacies.
In his engagement with blue poetics Dan Brayton pitches an argument that adheres to mutuality, suggesting that it is only “by imagining the ocean in terms of mutuality and belonging—as an entity to which we belong, rather than vice versa—can we begin to conceptualize it and act more ethically toward it.”9 Certainly, one cannot disown the connectedness of the human and the nonhuman, the human and the geological, as well as the terrestrial-human and the marine-nonhuman. Yet the relevance of uncanny hauntings and emergences cannot be excluded from ethical and affective engagements with contemporary physical accruals of anthropogenic climate crisis. Put simply, proximity and mutual sustenance do not gainsay feelings of estrangement in the context of climate change. Timothy Morton underscores this reality when he suggests that “coexistence is in our face; it is our face. We are made of nonhuman and non-sentient and non-living entities. It’s not a cozy situation; it’s a spooky, uncanny situation.”10 Morton’s point here refers to the relative porosities of the human body together with the genetic, biochemical, and physiological materials that animate and sustain the internal mechanics of our bodies.
In The Great Derangement novelist Amitav Ghosh clarifies the significance of the uncanny on larger, external scales. According to Ghosh,
No other word comes close to expressing the strangeness of what is unfolding around us. For these changes are not merely strange in the sense of being unknown or alien; their uncanniness lies precisely in the fact that in these encounters we recognize something we had turned away from: that is to say, the presence and proximity of nonhuman interlocutors.11
The apparent stability afforded through philosophical and ethical distancing between humanity and “nature” in the post-Enlightenment period in the Global North has been, according to Ghosh and other commentators, on the receiving end of concussive reality checks.12 For Ghosh the relevance of the uncanny in the era of climate emergencies—what has been dubbed the “Anthropocene” in many quarters—is that Freud’s notion speaks to the unsettling accruals of these emergencies in the everyday.13 Indeed, the Anthropocene has been limned in similar ways by Nils Bubandt as “a time when ghostly forces come to life in ways that are tainted through and through with strangeness.”14 The uncanny, then, disturbs the transparency and the equilibrium of what is assumed as normality, destabilizing the teleologies.15 Thus disturbance and excess are at the core of climate-emergency uncanniness as the boundaries between the human and the nonhuman, global and local scales, and the organic and the inorganic become blurred and meaningless.
The uncanny unmoors the routine certainties of the lives we live in the places that we invest with physical and emotional energies as we make homes and form bonds of friendship and community. In the context of climate change everything from our digestive systems, clothing, modes of transportation, homes, and means of technological communication and employment are discharged of passive neutrality. The entire panoply of daily life metamorphoses, thereby rendering the experiences and understandings of the world around us into something other than they have always appeared to be. Ironically, ecological connectedness—a mainstay of ecological thought—occasions the uneasiness of the climate uncanny; without intimacy the disquieting intrusions of the uncanny would not be possible.16 From another perspective, Naomi Booth captures the ways in which human bodies are displaced and dispersed in the era of Anthropocenic climate crises:
In the Anthropocene the human body proliferates, is doubled, duplicates itself into the world. Your body is in the sky as poison and climate turbulence. Your body is on the ground, doubling the dying of the creatures that you have killed. Your body is attending the corpseless funeral of the glacier that you have destroyed.17
While Booth’s point speaks directly to the manifestly deleterious imprints of anthropogenic climate pollution, such dispersal is no less true of nonhuman marine, chemical, and geological bodies. If our impacts mean that humanity will haunt the short- and long-term futures of the planet for millennia to come, that same volatility is in circulation in each and every moment of the present. While it might be affectively reassuring to repress the worst excesses of planetary climate change for those resident in the urban fastnesses of the Global North—preferring the mediated realities of extreme weather events and topographical devastation to its lived iterations—there is no way to escape the planetary natures of the ongoing, and imminent, crises.
At a local level an ostensibly benign civic initiative in Ireland furnishes a prefatory occasion to think through the relations between climate change, urban spaces, and the marine world in the context of the uncanny. For the entire month of August 2024 a temporary “urban” beach was installed on O’Connell Street in Limerick city. Deck chairs, sand, picnic benches, and other leisure furniture were positioned on the city’s main thoroughfare, with motorized traffic diverted away from the venue. The project was the brainchild of the newly elected mayor, John Moran—the first directly elected Mayor in Irish political history—and was designed to repurpose and reimagine the heart of the city.18 In a location that is beholden to travel by private car and that concedes very little to sustained pedestrian safety and convenience, the brief respite on one prominent stretch of the city’s transportation “real estate” can be read as both imaginative and symbolic. Needless to say, the project was met with skepticism as well as outright anger by invested business interests whose footfall depends upon allowing a steady stream of cars to dominate the city streets. In this case, surely not confined to Limerick city, the needs of the many must adapt to the needs of the balance sheets of the few. Unsurprisingly, the tensions surrounding the installation and the cordoning off of such a central transport artery underscore divergences in the imagination of what urban spaces can and should be, and of whom they can and should service. Such shortsightedness is familiar to most urban settings, with business turnover set at odds with the health and well-being of city dwellers and the ecological toll of motorized transportation.
The installation is a useful prompt to a broader discussion of climate change, and not simply because it can reveal the stress fractures in one relatively small city’s competing attitudes to ongoing environmental emergencies. The mayoral intent to import a degree of summer levity into the city and to point at alternative uses of local spaces are shadowed by forms of dislocation that are relevant to conversations on ongoing climate disruption and population precarity. The beach transposes one setting onto another—marine to urban—but hints at the prospect of flooding, erosion, and the febrile nature of the more-than-human world on foot of anthropogenic climate change. The physical installation of a beach onto the streets of an admittedly riverside city that is far removed from the coast throws the uncanniness of climate change into relief; it is, one might say, disturbingly anticipatory. Yet at the same time, as gestured to above, the installation is entirely recollective in the sense that it places marine origins at the heart of a bustling modern cityscape. Thus, in what appears to be a civic gesture facilitating a reorientation of space, there is also a complication of temporalities. The priorities and the teleologies of acceleration and progress are thereby problematized by a newly imposed deceleration. The streetscape becomes an ambivalent anticipatory synecdoche of what is possible in terms of “slow” urban redesign and, less cheerily, of the anthropogenically induced transformations of marine and coastal spaces. In referring to the installation’s uncanniness, we mean that once we truly consider the scales and potential accruals of unfettered anthropogenic climate change, our known world is altered into something unrecognizable yet not entirely alien.
The American marine biologist and environmentalist Rachel Carson is best known for her 1962 publication Silent Spring, which systematically revealed the widespread ecological devastation caused by the rampant employment of pesticides in the agricultural sector.19 But no less important is Carson’s earlier “marine” trilogy that began with the publication of Under the Sea-Wind in 1941, a book that was followed by The Sea Around Us in 1951 and completed with the appearance in 1955 of The Edge of the Sea.20 The trilogy was reissued in 2021, with Margaret Atwood providing introductory comments on Carson’s aggregation of marine texts. In her prefatory reflections Atwood insists that “the oceans are the living heart and lungs of our planet. They produce most of the oxygen in our atmosphere, and through their circulating currents they control climate. Without healthy oceans, we land-dwelling, air-breathing mid-sized primates will die.”21 Atwood offers a clinical account of the centrality of the planet’s oceanic ecologies to its resident life-systems, a point that is repeatedly ignored as millions of gallons of waste materials are ceaselessly dispatched into oceans, seas, and rivers. Such repetition is particularly pertinent here given that the uncanny cannot be separated from patterns of connectivity, similarity, and repetition.
At the same time, so much is unknown and unknowable about oceanic depths and the scarcely fathomable scalar proportions of their sizes and capacities. In contemporary ecocritical discourse planetary oceans are deemed “hyperobjects,” phenomena whose sizes and effects are so vast as to exceed the individual human imagination. Long before the philosophical densities of Morton’s work, Carson alights upon this scale in Under the Sea-Wind with a sobering portrait of the Atlantic Ocean off the eastern seaboard of North America:
Below them lay the abyss, the primeval bed of the sea, the deepest of all the Atlantic. The abyss is a place where change comes slow, where the passing of the years has no meaning, nor the swift succession of the seasons. The sun has no power in those depths, and so their blackness is a blackness without end, or beginning, or degree. No beating of tropical sun on the surface miles above can lessen the bleak iciness of those abyssal waters that varies little through summer or winter, through the years that melt into centuries, and the centuries into ages of geologic time. Along the floor of the ocean basins, the currents are a slow creep of frigid water, deliberate and inexorable as the flow of time itself.22
Plumbing the deepest recesses of the Atlantic, Carson evokes senses of distance and estrangement; this topography seems blissfully adrift from anthropocentric temporalities and spatialities. The deep ocean is shrouded in darkness, oblivious to and removed from the historical and cultural priorities of the terrestrial worlds at its surface. Yet even at the time of Carson’s evocative marine patternings, anthropogenic climate change was in process. In other words, simply because the most urgent impacts of climate change were not evidenced or measured at earlier historical junctures does not mean that humanity had not, and was not, affecting the ecological equilibria of global waterways and marine habitats. Likewise, there appears to be a “distance” between Atwood’s cri de coeur and Carson’s capacity to savor the shadowy remoteness of the Atlantic’s deepest corners. In bringing these views into constellation we glimpse the ambivalence and the uncanniness of the ongoing global climate emergencies, especially as they implicate the planet’s oceans and seas.
Both Atwood’s and Carson’s words register this feeling of ambivalence in their respective literariness, and they both embody and remind the reader of the protracted cultural production of the planet’s oceans. Excessive scale, extraordinary distances, and invisible depths have long been mediated and managed through the cultivation of anthropocentric narratives and figurations. Visual and verbal representations generate forms of knowable intimacies, scaling the vastness of global marine expanses down to human ratios. Yet such aesthetic intimacies cannot evade the chilling sublimities of the oceanic. If the seas and oceans are at once sites of and vehicles for historical and cultural changes, they are also originary locations in relation to evolutionary scales. As Dan Brayton confirms, “The sea is deeply part of human ontology; we share a strange and ancient kinship with marine animals. The human animal is, evolutionarily and somatically speaking, a creature of water, even if we do tend to live on land.”23 Thus, humanity’s enmeshment in the marine is both cultural-historical and biological-historical; the sea animates the abstractions of our imaginations as it courses through the fluids of our physical bodies.
More pressingly, the basis of all organic life on the planet is increasingly polluted, overheated, and thereby denuded of its capacities to sustain myriad life-forms. Equally, the overwhelming forces of the seas and oceans are increasingly unleashed on coastal geographies and populations in the forms of brutal weather events with accompanying tidal surges and flooding. In addition to threatening to engulf occupied landscapes, the rises in sea levels across the planet endanger human and nonhuman species. This catalogue of catastrophes speaks to the dependence that Atwood underscores. The underlying tension or ambivalence reveals how water sustains humanity and its economies and is a site of our species’ original birth and emergence, and yet we consciously and unremittingly commit to harming its sources. Steve Mentz captures this troubled relationship well: “[It is] the awkward fit between humans and water; we depend upon it and love it, but it cannot be our home.”24 Mentz is correct, notwithstanding the fact that it was our first home and that we begin life in utero as aquatic creatures. This somatic homeliness, the material intimacies of humanity’s “liquidity,” centers the uncanniness of daily experiences of global climate catastrophes.
While the primary focus of the following analyses of Mahon’s ecopoetics is on his latter collection Washing Up, the works under scrutiny here have many precursors across Mahon’s earlier publications. This is most apparent in “The Banished Gods,” a poem originally housed in his 1975 collection The Snow Party. Mahon writes, “Far from land, far from the trade routes, / in an unbroken dream-time / of penguin and whale, / the seas sigh to themselves / reliving the days before the days of sail.”25 The poem captures Mahon’s earliest poetic awareness of the wounds inflicted on global environments by the technological advancements of humanity, a perspective that threads through much of Mahon’s subsequent collections. As Ying Zhou maintains, “what is of particular importance in Mahon’s evolving poetics is a growing sensitivity to geopoetic vision that connects land and sea and forms a refreshed interconnectivity which opens up new routes for alternative possibilities of living/being.”26 Washing Up is a capstone in this sense, with its title evincing the usual Mahonian playfulness in pairing the suggestion of flotsam and jetsam “washing up“ on an incoming tide with the more prosaic image of routine domestic chores. This multivalence tallies with the climate uncanny because it brings the agencies and the scales of the oceanic alongside the privacies of the homestead. Indeed, the action of “washing up” the dishes also speaks to a feeling of “ongoingness,” a present in flux, and a flow into both the certainties and uncertainties of precarious future times.
“Atlantis,” the collection’s second poem, bears the hallmarks of a poetic thought experiment, an ironic imaginative projection of what a zero-sum technological panacea program would look like in the hands and philosophies of the people that have conjured up the worst excesses of global climate catastrophe. From another vantage point, “Atlantis” is an estranging seascape poem, a sequence that renders the recognizable in a disturbingly uncanny guise.27 Its epigraph from Paul Celan—“There are still songs to be sung beyond the human”—is crucial here, as it signals the poem’s focus on the depredations of humanism and anthropocentrism, specifically the unsustainable lifestyles from which it is nearly impossible to be weaned.28 The epigraphic “beyond the human“ thus underscores the specifically Western and capitalistic subject as the most culpable and rapacious iteration of “the human.”29 This version has been sanctified and codified under racialist, patriarchal, and ecophobic regimes since the early modern period. Indeed, Mahon seizes on the nomenclature of the “post-human” in the fifth sestet, which is noteworthy for its ironic portrait of a newly cleansed and freshly redeemed society that has given over menial labours to the products of technological innovation—“wised-up robots who do the real work.”30 The formal variety of the poem is expressive of the tonal ambivalence at play over the duration of “Atlantis.” Pointedly, the rhyme scheme in evidence across the poem’s seven sestets is consistently inconsistent. For instance, the poem transitions from an opening scheme of abcabc to abcdba in the succeeding sestet, so that while Mahon characteristically never abjures pattern entirely, the aural flow of the stanzas is less than uniform and never smoothly resonant.
Mahon’s epigraphic quotation bleeds into the grammatical structure of the poem’s opening line in the form of a thematic prompt, a musical catalyst that occasions an initial sestet that is all but evacuated of a definitive human presence: “These heard above the seismic turbulence / as when a blue whale or a giant squid / decides to emerge from its mysterious depth; / but this is a stranger miracle, intense / tectonic granite dripping with seaweed, / gemmed with barnacles like a salvaged ship.”31 The initial aural agencies of the poem deprioritize the human in both the epigraphic quotation and in the invocation of the largest creatures in the Earth’s oceans. Furthermore, Mahon empowers these non-human species with volition, they choose to inhabit the deepest fastnesses of the planet’s oceanic ecologies. Mahon’s gesture here stresses the unbridgeable unknowability of such nonhuman life-forms and, by underscoring their agency, establishes the poem’s ecological ethics. The simile that punctuates this sestet speaks to the implied future of ruination with which the poem is ultimately preoccupied. At once a vehicle and a figuration symbolizing the historical marine ambitions of anthropocentrism, the similized vessel is an entirely inadequate image for the proposed revivification of humanity’s civilizational “second coming.” The legacies of transatlantic trading in raw materials, consumer goods, and enslaved peoples are condensed into the figurative limits of a submerged relic.32
In the opening sestet Mahon convenes the geologic and the thalassic at immense scales, patterning a sequence in which the planet itself proffers a new beginning for humanity. The submarine reaches of the planet unveil a pristine topography replete with “gleaming surfaces / of new leaf and clean slate there for us / and our designs [ . . . ] / a new Atlantis / ripe with promise (I must be dreaming).”33 The answer to Mahon’s closing parenthetical query here is a resounding “yes”; the emerging land of opportunity is itself a mythic figuration, a frequently seen but never located mirage offering wealth or sanctuary. But the overheated fantasies of extractive and financialized capitalisms have yielded immense economic inequalities and, more pressingly, sharply unequal and devastating environmental consequences in real, material terms. The poem’s uncanny Atlantis mirrors the fantasies and lived realities under an environmentally destructive capitalism. The new “Atlantis” is yet another resource to be extracted from below the surface of the planet.
Mahon draws an ironic analogy between this utopian future and the unremitting mining of the Earth’s subterranean and submarine resources. The tone punctuating the poem is tinged with a countermeasure of pathos, given that the sole reason for the need for the salvific “Atlantis” to emerge is the wholesale and irreparable exhaustion of the planet. Nevertheless, this is a heavily ironized spectacle of resurrection and redemption, but equally it is an alert that the effects and inequalities of climate catastrophe cannot be alleviated or minimized via the same unfettered progress and exploitation. As Sam Solnick outlines:
The poem features the original lost continent returning from the sea to offer a different possible future . . . . Atlantis emerges offering “new leaf and clean slate,” but its “promise” turns out to be hollow. It is not so easy for individuals or societies to turn over new leaves. The poem presents new possibilities for two of the ecosystems most under threat in the Anthropocene (coral reefs and rainforests).34
In the third of the poem’s seven sestets, the renewed future of anthropocentric “civilization” is laid out in all of its fabricated specificity: “where we can plant our ideal society; / a coral shoreline fringed with cloud forest, / or a lost civilization, its architecture / waiting to be replaced by the white city / and wide roads of a fresh infrastructure: / poured concrete, aluminium, only the best.”35 The emerging topographies of edificial ruination and nonhuman beauty are little more than tabulae rasa on which the anthropocentric priorities will be imposed, or “planted,” in Mahon’s ironically ambivalent use of the verb. But in this instance the blooms and blossoms of nonhuman ecologies will be usurped by the industrial alloys and confections of human industry. The pristine will be substituted for the practical as the landscape and the functions of such landscapes tend towards a leveling and productive homogeneity. Indeed, the content and ethic of “Atlantis,” though appearing late in Mahon’s career, are of a piece with his earlier poetic and prose interventions on the urban sprawls of New York and of Celtic Tiger Dublin.36
In the sixth sestet, the poem dramatizes the blunt dichotomies informing capitalistic narratives of progress; across the six lines it appears that this is all but a zero-sum game in which the civilizational urgencies of the prevailing West will endure: “There will be cruise ships, the last savages / banished to caves and cabins, dubious sentiments / silenced, and the few relics of past ages / quickly recycled so no trace survives / of anything not in the future tense; / the sun will smile on our perfect lives.”37 Though trained on the future, the imagery here recalls nothing less than the violent histories of colonialism, legacies underpinned and legitimated by faith in the inferiority of indigenous cultures and in the incontrovertible virtues of exogenous moral and civilizational interventions. Latterly, as the opening clause of the sestet’s first line underscores, economic and environmental inequalities and violences have become more pronounced; the poem figuratively registers superficially benign, or “slow” forms of violence in the guise of marine engineering in the service of the tourist industry.38 And in this way the “cruise ships” of Mahon’s poem are haunted by the darker histories of shipping and transportation on the planet’s marine thoroughfares. The seascapes that populate “Atlantis” are remote from the “quiet shores” and “friendly tide” lyricized so plangently in “Dreams of a Summer Night” from Harbour Lights.39
The estranging memories of previous transatlantic passages shadow the luxuriant vessels of late capitalism. But as we noted at the outset of our analysis of Mahon’s ecopoetics, environmental displacement and ecological catastrophe continue across his oeuvre. This is spotlit in the second line of the sixth sestet of “Atlantis” with the telling reference to the “last savages / banished to caves” (my emphasis).40 In the earlier poem “The Banished Gods” Mahon limns the alienation occasioned by unrelenting economic and technological innovation. If the earlier verse is remarkable for its tonal pathos, “Atlantis” cannot suppress a critical and ironic voice in the face of equivalent contemporary banishments. Just as the “banished gods” must sit out the worst excesses and exercises of anthropogenic climate devastation, so too must the “banished” savages silently endure—out of sight—the newly forged “perfect lives” of late capitalism. Mahon’s ambivalence is built into the formal architecture of the poem, and this is pointedly conveyed via the rhyme scheme of the sixth sestet. At the ends of lines one and three, respectively, the aforementioned “last savages” are kin to the “relics of past ages” of which, at the close of line four, “no trace survives.” The stanza opens with “There will be cruise ships, the last savages / banished to caves and cabins, dubious sentiments / silenced, and the few relics of past ages.”41 Yet crucially, in the sixth and final line of the sestet, Mahon rhymes “survives” with “our perfect lives,” a choice that does not perpetuate difference nor tolerate distinction between past and future, or between the obsolete and the modern. The sound conjunctions are conscious patterns, aural correlatives of the ecological and ethical imports of “Atlantis.” The notion of “our perfect lives” might well punctuate the sestet, but the rhymed connection construed by Mahon insists that such apparent perfection is as transient and disposable as that which it exploits into extinction and exhaustion.
Mahon’s “Algae” sequence—a poetic triptych—consists of “Wrack,” “Dulse,” and “Kelp,” respectively. The sequence toggles thematically between locality and globality, materiality and abstraction, humanity and nonhumanity, the individual and the communal, and micro- and macroscales. Each of the poems asks questions of the human reader, urging them to re-think the seemingly most simple and abundant of marine organisms: seaweed. But the poems are also alive to the ways in which anthropocentric profiteering and cultural mediation have processed and exploited the diversity of lives native to the seas and the oceans. Myth, human history, evolutionary history, cultural representation, and personal memory are thus confected into a suite of ecopoetic meditations. Each of the three poems consists of twenty-four lines in four sestets of rhymed couplets. The structure grants the poems a symmetry that affords structural symmetry to the poems, individually and as a collective. Yet such formal balance is offset by the sequence’s animation. The poems direct their attention to the possibility, indeed the likelihood, of ecological degradation and extinction in marine life. Exploitation and estrangement course through the content and structure of the poems. The poems center on the birth of what became much later the alluring and sublime seascapes of human experience, while the soundscape of the poems register the familiar ambivalence of Mahon’s ecopoetics. In the first poem’s title, “Wrack,” Mahon impresses the harsh punctuation of its closing consonantal digraph “ck,” a note that scores the remaining four stanzas. Across the sestets Mahon places in the following order the words “rock,” “wrack,” “back,” “struck,” “wrack,” “rocks,” “mock,” and “shock”; these are in addition to “broke,” “secret,” and “strikes”.42 The cleaving and crushing of the developing planetary environment finds an aural correlative here, a sonic harshness that reverberates across the body of the poem that also gestures to our contemporary planet that is time-stamped with the agencies, forces, and sounds of its deeper history.
The opening sestet of “Wrack” situates the reader in an originary space, suggesting a time and a place that is devoid of humanity, a context into which humanity has not yet evolved or intruded: “There came an era when steam first / started condensing into mist / and cloud, when the first rains broke / roaring on sedimentary rock; / when hot streams of detritus ran / and the first signs of growth began.”43 Process and the passage of time inaugurate the poem from its first words, pursued by geological and meteorological action. But crucially Mahon invokes the seas in which the titular “wrack” is native; the common source of organic life swells into being, cascading over the emergent and ever-changing planet’s geological blooms. This is a deeply transhistorical introduction to the poem, yet is unsurprising given that Mahon precedes the poem with the following epigraphic quotation from Charles Darwin: “If in any country a forest was destroyed, I do not believe so many species would perish as would, here, from destruction of the kelp.”44 As has been underscored earlier, connection and spoliation are central to ongoing climate crises, and they are cornerstones of philosophical, ethical, and aesthetic responses to these same ecological emergencies. Darwin’s point reinforces Mahon’s poetic iterations of mutualism, alienation, and exploitation. By enlisting Darwin’s voice, Mahon invokes a foundational intervention in the displacement of humanity and human histories in terms of evolutionary time scales. In other words, Darwin’s presence and quotation illuminates the uncanny dislocations central to the climate crisis.
The uncanniness of climate crisis is legible in Mahon’s attention to a deep past that is denuded of human agency, a physical landscape that is our planet but is totally unrecognizable. There are, of course, elemental, mineral, and biochemical continuities across vast eons of planetary history, connections that form the necessary intimacies of all uncanny experiences. David Farrier addresses the “spectrality” of future-oriented deep time, noting how our contemporary climatic imprints will haunt future generations of human and nonhuman life on earth. Farrier makes the point that deep time “is not an abstract, distant prospect, but a spectral presence in the everyday. The irony of the Anthropocene is that we are conjuring ourselves as ghosts that will haunt the very deep future.”45 In the future, for Farrier, the disposable and toxic detritus of consumer convenience will persist in material forms as well as in less visible but no less noxious terms.
Equally, the present is no longer as stable as it might appear. It has been temporally and spatially distended beyond the scales of human time and space. This is expressed once again by Mahon in the sequence’s second poem, “Dulse,” when he refers to “the salt breath / of our dark origins amid / slow-to-develop squirts and squid. [. . .] a time / when we had scarcely quite the slime. [. . .] and even, who knows, the distant age / before our own crowd took the stage.”46 If the first shoots of organic life are tracked in “Wrack,” humanity registers as a primitive life-force in this latter poem. With a typically ironic flourish at the close of “Dulse,” Mahon inserts a self-deprecating reference to “our own crowd” who “took the stage,” a note of irony reinforced by a knowing allusion to Shakespeare’s figuration in As You Like It about the contexts and conditions of human life. The ironic reference to the fleeting nature of human existence seen here in “Dulse” echoes the previous diminution of an anthropocentric worldview evident in the final pairing of lines in “Wrack,” wherein the seaweed’s “wild insurgency” appears “to mock our easy common sense / and shock our breezy confidence.”47 There is, then, an aggregated recognition of shared evolutionary longevity in these two poems that in ecological terms evokes mutualism and respect without erasing difference. This recognition persists in dislocating the present from itself through a confounding sense of organic and evolutionary filiality. In Mahon’s hands the genetic and biochemical intersections and porosities of all earthly matter do not lapse into ecological sentimentality. Rather, the sequence retains an ironic ecopoetical perspective on human history and potential.
Notably, in both “Dulse” and “Kelp”—the second and third poems of the triptych—Mahon moves from the collective “our” to the first-person singular. While the first-person singular is deployed, however, its affect demonstrably diverges. The lyric “I” is displaced from the present tense of the writing, speaking, and reading acts: “Thinking of the red dulse we knew / at seaside places years ago, / its leafy weave and dusky taste, / I’m back there on the Antrim coast. […] If dreams reveal not just the real / biography of a single soul / but the whole history of the race, / even my dulse dream has its place.”48 The topographies of the poetic voice, including a recurring Mahonian recollection of a coastal location, here are rooted in memory and in the unconscious, while the actualities of the present are further unsettled. In “Dulse” the speaker’s perspective remains unhitched from the present, indeed the present is stalked by the past and by the unconscious.
The tone of the voice changes gear, however, in “Kelp,” in which the urgencies and spoliation of marine life are made plain, as the first-person singular rises to the levels of ecological polemic. In this final poem of the triptych the voice is at once strident in the face of the sundering of both marine and terrestrial ecologies, while the poem reprises Mahon’s ironic touch with its invocation of Robert Flaherty’s film, Man of Aran: “Maggie Dirrane / from Bob Flaherty’s Man of Aran, / with a big load of kelp and wrack / stacked like turf on her broad back.”49 Flaherty’s work is an instance of cultural mediation, but it also represents a lapse into stereotype and cliché, a cinematic artifact that remains far removed from the lived materialities of coastal dwelling. While the poem is thus transfused with a measure of levity, the closing sestet insists on the urgency of ecological devastation: “Even as I write this I can hear / a chainsaw cough and start to clear / the hillside of its remaining trees / for building on. Don’t do it, please! / just let the old birch and hazel be, / and the cloud forests of the sea.”50 These lines are present-centered and future-oriented, grounding the speaker in the contemporaneity of global environmental crises both terrestrial and marine. The repetition of the first-person singular underscores the anthropogenic nature of these crises, to which the poetic speaker, and the poem’s implied reader, are both held accountable. Clear competing strains are audible here, with the mechanical assault of the “chainsaw” set against the later, resolving notes. The sounds of clearing “the hillside” are counterbalanced, and ultimately superseded, by the closing rhymed couplet of “Kelp,” which rhymes “be” with “sea.” The poem closes with an affirmation of the sea’s existence and right to thrive. Mahon’s seaweed triptych navigates planetary history via the evolution of the seas and its diversity of organic life while intermittently casting an ironic eye on the ways in which humanity has leveraged the accruals of marine evolution into crudely and damaging commercial opportunities. The latter are repeatedly displaced, however, as Mahon decenters the temporal and spatial scales of human life, making our home planet seem newly strange and uncanny.
In a 2015 piece that appeared in The New Yorker, the novelist Jonathan Franzen engaged with a recently published book by the environmental philosopher Dale Jamieson. Reason in a Dark Time was published in 2014, and Franzen admits to having been taken by the book’s subtitle, Why the Struggle against Climate Change Failed—And What It Means for Our Future.51 Franzen writes about the way in which Jamieson bases the definitiveness of his claim on the fact that climate change is a matter that defies human rationality:
Jamieson’s larger contention is that climate change is different in category from any other problem the world has ever faced. For one thing, it deeply confuses the human brain, which evolved to focus on the present, not the far future, and on readily perceivable movement, not slow and probabilistic developments [ . . . ]. The great hope of the Enlightenment—that human rationality would enable us to transcend our evolutionary limitations—has taken a beating from wars and genocides, but only now, on the problem of climate change, has it foundered altogether.52
The inherent excessiveness of climate change is the core of the problematic. It pinpoints why the uncanny, with its temporal and spatial scalar proportions, is so germane to ethical and aesthetic reckonings. If climate change “confuses the human brain,” what are the implications of, or possibilities for, such disorientation? Can these kinds of experiences be parlayed into awareness and acknowledgement of individual and communal ecological responsibilities?
Simply put, perhaps confusion, estrangement, and disorientation are necessary stages in environmental recognition because so-called focus, clarity, and rationality have accrued nothing less than global climate catastrophe—hence the value of the aesthetic deployment of the uncanny in poetry such as Mahon’s, a poetics that, in the cases outlined above, brings the estranged familiarity of the seas and oceans into routine, domestic, and consumer lives. And while Mahon’s turn to the seas in the context of environmental degradation is not new in his work, it is of a piece with more recent critical developments in the so-called “blue humanities.” Mahon’s works coalesce with a body of critical materials that attend to what Serpil Oppermann dubs “storied water,” or “the fluid ground on which the imaginary and the actual intersect in real and symbolic contexts.”53 Rather than see water, or bodies of water, as passive backdrops to human-centred activity and exploitation, the blue humanities highlights the “crucial role oceans play in shaping world cultures, literary narratives, aesthetic sensibilities, artworks, economies, politics, moral codes, sciences, and even languages.”54 In its own way this broad theoretical reorientation is uncanny and destabilizing given how it repositions the ontological and epistemological roles of humanity and marine life.